GOD AND CHRISTIANITY
Essay
1975
I do not consider myself to be a "Christian"
nor do I wish to be considered one, nor for
that matter do I think that Friends should
take any stock in Christianity, at least as it is
traditionally believed. For that matter, I do
not believe in God; but neither do I disbelieve
in God nor do I consider myself to be an agnostic;
the existence or non-existence of such a
being is irrelevant to how we should live our lives.
Christianity has from its inception made several
erroneous assumptions concerning itself, its founder
and its mission. From the beginning it has had a
fundamental misunderstanding of the intentions and
teachings of Jesus, as even a cursory inspection
of the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, and Luke -- the Synoptic
Gospels -- will reveal; while the Gospel of John
tends to support theological Christianity
the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, and Luke do not;
and the picture presented in John is inconsistent
with the picture presented in the Synoptics. One
of the erroneous assumptions that Christianity
has made is that not only was it the only true
religion but that a fundamental aspect of itself
was to convert the rest of the world -- in other
words, to twist the minds of everyone else around
to believe their way. Christianity has
substituted for graven images of other religions and
the elaborate observance of ritual and sacrifices
of the Jews of Jesus' time a worship of belief in
Jesus, of theology about Jesus and salvation in a
future life.
In trying to understand religion and how to live my life
I come at some point to consider the Two Commandments
as either approved of or put together by Jesus, although
originally stated by Moses in the first five books of the
Bible -- Love God supremely, and love your neighbor
as yourself. It is clear from Jesus' teachings as recorded
in the parable of the Good Samaritan and in certain statements
in the Sermon on the Mount that everyone was to be
included in the definition of neighbor, i.e. if you love
only those who are good to you, what do you do more than
everyone else? therefore you should be all-inclusive in
your love, even as God is all-inclusive in his love
sending his rain and sunshine on every being, good or evil
just or unjust.
However, I am unable to reach an understanding
of what is meant by loving God supremely. I can
at least try to love everyone, even those who try
to harm me; I can see people and see their responses and
feel close to them even if I may misunderstand and
misinterpret their behavior, because I have some sense
that we experience the same feelings and desires
and needs. But I cannot "see" God; I cannot "feel" God;
the only sense I can make out of the first commandment
is that it is actually the same as the second commandment:
God is in fact other people, as well as myself;
their goodness, their happiness, their suffering
their needs and wants are no different than mine. God is
collective humanity, or more broadly still all collective
life; there is no being in existence who is inferior to me
or to which or whom I am not alike in many ways.
(originally published under the name of John Fitz)